Our Mission
WE HELP TO PUT LIVES BACK TOGETHER.
We work to know our clients and thier needs. This enables us to educate them as to which products match their needs. As an agency, we always place business with financially stable companies, so when the unexpected happens, we can help to put our client's life back together.
Our Vision
TRUST
RELATIONSHIPS COMMUNICATION
We are a team of dedicated insurance professionals who are committed to adding value to each other, our clients and the communities we serve.
We believe healthy communication is the key that allows us to engage with our clients and each other in a genuine and caring fashion.
Tasha Fuhrman
I joined Reynolds Insurance Agency in December 2017. I first worked with Craig and Brandon on farm renewals, changes, and claims. I was given the opportunity to transfer to crop insurance in the winter of 2019, where I really grew to appreciate all that crop insurance and all the government programs have to offer to our farmers and ranchers.
Crop Insurance
Licensed Agent
I grew up on my family farm outside of Plaza. I spent most of my time outdoors, playing and caring for the various farm animals we had, reading a lot of books, and working on the farm. I went to college in MN, where I graduated from Alexandria Technical College with a cert. in carpentry. I met my husband in college, and we moved to North Dakota after college. I worked as a carpenter for 7 years before I decided to make a change in my career path.
When you don’t find me behind the desk, keying acreage reports or production, you can find me out on the lake in the boat, sitting on the ice pulling walleyes up, or out walking/running down our desolate country roads (usually accompanied by one of several of my barn cats). I like to spend time with my family and friends, keep our son entertained with all that country living offers like 4 wheelers and skidsteers, and when it all calms down for a minute, I may get a few pages read in a book.
Life & Health
Licensed Agent
Cambry Fyllesvold
I joined the Reynolds Insurance Agency team in May 2025 as a Customer Service Representative. During my first few months, I worked toward becoming a licensed insurance agent and successfully passed my final exam on September 9, 2025.
Licensed Agent
Within the agency, I primarily assist clients with their auto and home insurance needs, along with helping promote the agency through online marketing and community events.
I grew up on a farm near Plaza, ND, and later in Mandan, ND, where I completed both my schooling and athletic activities.
After graduation, I moved back to Plaza to be closer to my family in the surrounding area.
In my free time, I enjoy attending sporting events, NoDak Speedway race nights, golfing, traveling, spending time with my family, and playing with my cat.
Brandon Turnbow
I joined the team in 2007 as a licensed agent and office manager for the Stanley location. In 2014, facing staffing issues, both offices were consolidated and I moved to the New Town office. Eventually I became the manager of the New Town location. I work with the farm & commercial accounts as well as crop hail & multi-peril crop insurance in the summer.
Licensed Agent
I’m originally from Idaho Falls, ID and I moved to North Dakota in 1999, where I met my wife. I later attended Bible school at AFLBS in Plymouth, MN and after getting married, my wife and I relocated to Memphis with my work. Eventually our family found our way back to North Dakota upon joining the Reynolds Insurance Agency team.
My wife and I live on a small farm south of Berthold with our family, where we raise goats, horses, and 4-H rabbits. Our oldest son was recently married and now lives in South Dakota with our daughter-in-law, where he attends college and plays football for the Northern State Wolves.
Outside of work, I enjoy working on projects around the farm, spending time with my family, and taking in my sons’ various extracurricular activities.
Dorothy Ventsch
I began working at Reynolds Insurance Agency in 2006 and I became licensed in the same year. I work with crop and hail insurance and also do some bookkeeping for the agency.
Crop Insurance
Licensed Agent
Prior to joining the agency, I worked at the local bank for 25 years, primarily in the bookkeeping and IT department. I have a 2 year degree in agribusiness from Williston State College.
When I have time, I enjoy reading, needlework, gardening, and hiking.
Craig Reynolds
I started working in the insurance industry as a captive agent for Farmers Union Insurance on September 1, 1991 in Stanley ND. In March of 1997 I left the captive agency side of the business to become an Independent Agent operating as Reynolds Insurance Agency second location in Stanley, ND which is located 32 miles north of New Town.
Licensed Agent
On January 1, 2003 I purchased the agency from my father and assumed full leadership and management responsibility.
I graduated from New Town High School in 1987 and went on to pursue a Business Degree at Jamestown College in Jamestown, ND.
In 1991 I graduated from Jamestown College with a Bachelors of Arts degree in Business Administration with a minor in Managerial Information Science.
I have been happily married to my wife since 1993 and we have 3 wonderful children.
Outside of work I enjoy snowmobiling in the Mountains of MT and ID, hunting, fishing and working on collectible vehicles.
Gisele Carter
I joined Reynolds Insurance Agency in March of 2017, and in December of the same year I applied for and earned my insurance license. After a year assisting with the farm accounts I have been rewarded with the opportunity to manage Reynolds Insurance marketing.
Licensed Agent
I am originally from Sao Paulo, Brazil, a state with a population of over
23 million people as of 2026 census.
I come from a family of five and I’m the oldest daughter. I came to the US in December 2011 for the Work & Travel exchange student program through the Agency “CI - Central de Intercambio”.
I lived in Devils Lake and while I was there I met this very interesting guy from Ohio, who came to North Dakota for Law Enforcement and to play Football for Lake Region State College.
I returned to Brazil in April 2012 and graduated from the Universidade Metodista de Sao Paulo with a major in Social Communication & Marketing.
After graduation, I returned to the USA and my husband and I decided to get married. We now have a family of five.
I have fallen in love with the insurance industry, and the chance to touch people's lives, and in my “off-time,” my family expends time traveling, baking, fishing or soaking in my husband’s passion for vehicles.
